*** Friends was founded by Marjory Stoneman Douglas ***
To: Members of Congress:
We have one urgent reason for asking you to eliminate the sugar subsidies
in the Farm Bill: Government aid to the sugar industry is hampering government
efforts to save the Everglades.
The nation is preparing to spend more than 8 billion dollars over 40
years to rescue Florida's vitally important Everglades ecosystem while
at the same time it is handing multi-millions to the sugar cane growers
who primarily are responsible for the perilous condition of this ecosystem.
The problem is not just the money that the growers get from this classic
example of corporate welfare. The problem also is that these federal handouts
enable the farmers to stay in the Everglades and continue to threaten its
demise.
Huge swaths of Everglades are being poisoned by the pollution-laden
water pumped off the sugar fields. These releases contained 425 tons of
phosphorus last year. An ever-expanding area of Everglades is choked by
thick stands of cattails that replace Everglades vegetation, shut out wildlife
and interrupt water flow. Three to five aces of Everglades die every day.
Pollutants from the cane fields also are pouring into Lake Okeechobee and
turning it putrid despite a flurry of lawsuits and legal mandates to halt
this outrage. A state Everglades cleanup program (The Everglades Forever
Act), that sticks the South Florida taxpayer with most of the cost, is
not doing the job.
Almost half a million acres of sugar cane is growing in the Everglades
Agricultural Area south of Lake Okeechobee. The EAA, as it is known, was
created for the farmers free of charge by the Army Corps of Engineers about
50 years ago. The Corps drained 700,000 acres in the heart of the
Everglades at the headwaters of the River of Grass, that wide, shallow
movement of water that sustains the Everglades. Think of it-700,000 acres,
more than a thousand square miles. The drained land stretches about 50
miles at its widest and deepest points.
The Corps also installed some of the world's largest pumps and deepened
and widened major canals to keep the EAA dry. These pumps and canals, with
their locks and levees, operate at taxpayers expense.
Besides being the major polluter, the EAA is responsible for many other
problems in the Everglades that include:
.
· Tremendous loss of fresh water to sea. An average of
130 million gallons a year is flushed away to keep the EAA dry. This is
water that once recharged the Everglades system. Water storage, in the
EAA and other places, is critical to restore the Everglades.
· .Disruption of the entire hydrology and ecology. This
is the consequence of maintaining a drained area in the middle of the Everglades
watershed. The Everglades now is cut off from Lake Okeechobee, which periodically
overflowed its banks into the River of Grass. Besides being polluted, the
water now fails to move at the right depth at the right time over the right
space. The disrupted flow to Everglades National Park and Florida Bay has
caused a 90 percent loss of wading birds and serious damage to the fishing
grounds, including the Ten Thousand Islands and the Florida Keys. In addition,
68 species of plans and animals found in South Florida are threatened or
endangered.
· Staggering loss of soil. The peat and muck that lies above
the limestone base is
disappearing, as happens when organic soil is drained. Some land in
the EAA already
has gone out of production because the soil is too thin. The U.S. Geological
Survey
predicts farming will cease "within decades". The only way to stop
the loss is to put
the water back on the land. The Everglades once contained the largest
body of
organic soil in the world. It takes a century to form one inch.
It takes just a few years
to lose it when drained.
· Threat of urban sprawl. When the EAA is no longer farmed it
it expected to be
developed. Urbanization already presses against the borders of the
EAA, which is commuting distance from the crowded East Coast. Funds used
to subsidize the sugar farmers should be diverted to buy land in the EAA
and return it as nearly as possible to its natural condition.
· Restoration slowdown. To save some of the water wasted
to sea, government
purchased 60,000 acres in the EAA for
$152 million as the site for water storage
reservoirs. Yet sugar cane continues
to grow on this public land. Construction of the
first reservoir is not scheduled to
begin until 2005, if then, because of opposition from
sugar interests.
· Subsidies that pick the people's pockets. Sugar gets supports
that keep the price
artificially high, costing consumers
$2 billion last year and driving candy makers and
other manufacturers to foreign countries.
The growers get low interest government
loans backed by future crops. Forfeitures
are allowed. This year the federal govern
government bought more than $400 million
of surplus sugar it has no use for. It costs
the taxpayers $1.3 million a month to
store this sugar in industry warehouses.
The South Florida Water Management District uses funds from property
owners
in 16 counties to operate water management
systems solely for the benefit of the
EAA. One study estimated that the EAA gets $238 million a year in public
assistance.
The state program that attempts to clean up pollution from the cane fields
costs
the growers only 15 percent of the $1.6 billion
cost.
· Favoritism in government water management. When South
Florida cities were subject to
drastic water restrictions during a recent
drought, the government water managers drained
almost three feet---150
billion gallons---off of Lake Okeechobee to irrigate the sugar fields.
Conversely, last year when Lake Okeechobee was too high and about a foot
of water
was drained to protect the environment, all of South Florida estuaries
and the Everglades got
soaked with polluted water. Water managers declared
that all areas were "sharing adversity".
But the sugar fields were exempt.
They remained dry.
The lake is considered a water storage area both for the EAA and the
urban
coast. But the EAA draws an average
of 170 million gallons a day, while only an
average of 13 million gallons
a day are sent to recharge coastal well fields.
The Water Management District is run by a board of directors appointed
by the
governor and traditionally dominated
by agricultural interests. The board shares
water management decisions with
the Army Corps of Engineers. At times it appears
that the whole Everglades system
is run primarily for the benefit of the EAA and the
occupying sugar interests instead
of for the natural system of four million acres on
which the whole region depends
for clean fresh water.
Because Congress approved the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan
(CERP) last year many people think the Everglades is saved and they can
stop worrying about it. But in that they are very much mistaken because
government continues to support the very sources that are destroying the
Everglades.
.
The Everglades can't take any more of this abuse. Please help rescue
it by eliminating the sugar subsidies from the Farm Bill.
FRIENDS OF THE EVERGLADES
|